TABLE OF CONTENTS

 

 

1    INTRODUCTION

Background

Purpose of the EIA Stud

Objectives of the EIA Study

Key Environmental Issues and Study Approach

Structure of EIA Report

 

2    PROJECT DESCRIPTION

The Need and Justification for the Project

Consideration of Alternative Options

Selection of Preferred Scenario

Description of the Project

Construction and Demolition Methodology0

Cremation Technology

Design of the Cremators2

Air Pollution Control Technology3

Benefits of the Project5

Interactions with Other Projects5

 

3    AIR QUALITY

Introduction

Description of the Project

Environmental Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria

Description of the Environment

Air Sensitive Receivers

Identification of Environmental Impacts

Assessment Methodology1

Prediction and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts6

Mitigation of Adverse Environmental Impacts

Evaluation of Residual Impacts

Environmental Monitoring and Audit

Conclusion

 

4    WASTE MANAGEMENT

Introduction

Environmental Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria

Project Description

Assessment Methodology

Identification of Environmental Impacts

Prediction and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts for Construction and Demolition Phase

Prediction and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts for Operation Phase

Mitigation of Adverse Environmental Impacts for Construction and Demolition Phase

Mitigation of Adverse Environmental Impacts for Operation Phase

Impacts Caused by Handling, Collection and Disposal of Waste

Evaluation of Residual Impacts

Cumulative Impacts due to Concurrent Projects

Conclusion

 

5    LAND CONTAMINATION

Introduction

Environmental Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria

Description of the Environment

Identification of Sensitive Receivers

Identification of Environmental Impacts

Prediction and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts

Mitigation of Adverse Environmental Impacts

Evaluation of Residual Impacts

Recommended Health and Safety Measures and Environmental Mitigation Measures

Conclusion

 

6    VISUAL IMPACT

Introduction

Environmental Legislation, Standards and Guidelines

Assessment Methodology

Scope and Content of the Study

Review of Planning and Development Control Framework

Baseline Study

Visual Impact Assessment

Environmental Monitoring and Audit

Conclusion

 

7    NOISE

Introduction

Environmental Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria

Description of the Environment

Identification of Environmental Impacts

Assessment Methodology

Prediction and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts

Mitigation of Environmental Impacts

Evaluation of Residual Impacts0

Environmental Monitoring and Audit0

Conclusion1

 

8    WATER QUALITY

Introduction

Environmental Legislation, Policies, Plans, Standards and Criteria

Water Sensitive Receivers

Assessment Methodology

Identification of Environmental Impacts

Prediction and Evaluation of Environmental Impacts

Mitigation of Adverse Environmental Impacts

Evaluation of Residual Impacts

Environmental Monitoring and Audit

Conclusion

 

9    ENVIRONMENTAL OUTCOMES

The Project

Key Environmental Impacts

Key Environmental Outcomes

 

10   ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING AND AUDIT REQUIREMENTS

Introduction

Air Quality

Waste Management

Land Contamination

Visual Impact

Noise

Water Quality

 

11   CONCLUSION

Air Quality

Waste Management

Land Contamination

Visual Impact

Noise

Water Quality

Overall Conclusion

 

12   IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE OF RECOMMENDED MITIGATION MEASURES

 

 

List of Tables

 

Table 2.1           Environmental Benefits and Dis-benefits of Feasible Extension Projects

Table 3.1           Hong Kong Air Quality Objectives

Table 3.2           Air Quality Criteria for non-AQO Pollutants

Table 3.3           Health Risk Guideline for Exposure to Cancer Risk Pollutants

Table 3.4           Background Air Pollutant Concentrations adopted in the Study

Table 3.5           Identified Air Sensitive Receivers

Table 3.6           Construction/Demolition Works Programme of the Project

Table 3.7           Comparison of Emission Limits of Various Air Pollutants for Existing and New Cremators

Table 3.8           Emission Limits of Various Air Pollutants0

Table 3.9           Emission Factors for Construction Activities and Wind Erosion2

Table 3.10         Design of Chimneys3

Table 3.11          Maximum Emission Rates of Various Air Pollutants3

Table 3.12         Value Adopted for Exposure Frequency, Exposure Duration and Average Time6

Table 3.13         Predicted Hourly and Daily Average TSP Concentrations During Construction Phase6

Table 3.14         Predicted Highest Concentration of Various Air Pollutants at ASRs

Table 4.1           Estimated Quantity of C&D Materials to be Generated, Reused and Disposed of

Table 4.2           Summary of Recommended Disposal Routes from C&D Works During Phase 1 and

                        Phase 2

Table 4.3           Maximum Quantity of Bone Ash and Non-combustible Residues

Table 4.4           Summary of Recommended Disposal Routes during Operation Phase0

Table 4.5           Proposed Contamination Classifications for Ash Waste2

Table 5.1           Reviewed Historical Aerial Photographs

Table 5.2.......... Laboratory Results Summary

Table 5.3.......... Estimated Quantity of Contaminated Soil

Table 5.4.......... Potential Soil Remediation Technologies

Table 5.5.......... Universal Treatment Standards (UTS) for the Concerned Heavy Metals0

Table 6.1.......... Relationship between Receptor Sensitivity and Impact Magnitude in Defining Impact Significance

Table 6.2.......... Visual Sensitive Receivers (VSRs) and their Sensitivity to Change

Table 6.3.......... Visual Sensitive Receivers (VSRs) and Their Magnitude of Impacts

Table 6.4.......... Proposed Visual Mitigation Measures for Construction Phase0

Table 6.5.......... Proposed Visual Mitigation Measures for Operation Phase0

Table 6.6.......... Significance of Visual Impacts in the Construction and Operation Phase3

Table 7.1.......... Area Sensitivity Ratings (ASRs)

Table 7.2.......... Acceptable Noise Levels for Construction Work (Restricted Hours)

Table 7.3.......... Acceptable Noise Levels for Fixed Noise Sources

Table 7.4.......... Details of Representative Noise Sensitive Receivers

Table 7.5.......... Summary of Unmitigated Construction Noise Levels at Representative NSRs during

....................... Normal Daytime Working Hours

Table 7.6.......... Predicted Operation Noise Levels at Representative NSRs (Newly Proposed Equipment – Unmitigated Scenario)

Table 7.7.......... Predicted Operation Noise Levels During Transitional Period (Existing Equipment + New Equipment under Phase 1)

Table 7.8.......... Summary of Mitigated Construction Noise Levels at Representative NSRs during Normal

....................... Daytime Working Hours (Use of Quiet PME)

Table 7.9.......... Predicted Operation Noise Levels at Representative NSRs (Newly Proposed Equipment – Mitigated Scenario)0

Table 8.1.......... Summary of Water Quality Objectives for the Eastern Buffer WCZ

Table 9.1.......... Key Environmental Impacts

Table 12.1........ Implementation Schedule for Air Quality Control

Table 12.2........ Implementation Schedule for Waste Management

Table 12.3........ Implementation Schedule for Land Contamination8

Table 12.4........ Implementation Schedule for Visual Impact

Table 12.5........ Implementation Schedule for Noise Control

Table 12.6........ Implementation Schedule for Water Quality Control

 

 

List of Figures

 

Figure 1.1          Site Location Plan

Figure 2.1          Alternative Extension Options at Adjacent Sites

Figure 2.2          Alternative In-situ Extension of Existing Crematorium

Figure 2.3          Block Plan (Phase 1)

Figure 2.4         Block Plan (Phase 1 and Phase 2)

Figure 2.5          Floor Plans 

Figure 2.6          Sections of Crematorium

Figure 2.7          Tentative Construction Programme

Figure 3.1          Locations of Representative Air Sensitive Receivers

Figure 3.2          Contours of Maximum 1-Hour Average TSP Concentration in mg/m3 at 1.5m above Ground – Phase 1

Figure 3.3          Contours of Maximum 24-Hour Average TSP Concentration in mg/m3 at 1.5m above Ground – Phase 1

Figure 3.4          Contours of Maximum 1-Hour Average TSP Concentration in mg/m3 at 1.5m above Ground – Phase 2

Figure 3.5          Contours of Maximum 24-Hour Average TSP Concentration in mg/m3 at 1.5m above Ground – Phase 2

Figure 3.6          Contours of Maximum 24-Hour Average RSP Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.7          Contours of Maximum 1-Hour Average TOC Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.8          Contours of Maximum 24-Hour Average TOC Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.9          Contours of Maximum 1-Hour Average HCL Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.10        Contours of Annual Average HCL Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.11        Contours of Maximum 1-Hour Average CO Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.12        Contours of Maximum 8-Hour Average CO Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.13        Contours of Maximum 1-Hour Average Mercury Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.14        Contours of Annual Average Mercury Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.15        Contours of Annual Average Dioxins Concentration in pg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.16        Contours of Maximum 1-Hour Average NO2 Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.17        Contours of Maximum 24-Hour Average NO2 Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.18        Contours of Maximum 1-Hour Average SO2 Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 3.19        Contours of Maximum 24-Hour Average SO2 Concentration in mg/m3 at 166.5mPD

Figure 5.1          Structural Layout of the Existing Crematorium

Figure 5.2          Sampling Locations

Figure 5.3          Estimated Contamination Extent.

Figure 5.4          Proposed Confirmatory Sampling Locations

Figure 6.1         Existing Aerial Photography

Figure 6.2         Planning & Development Framework (OZP)

Figure 6.3         Visual Contour Map

Figure 6.4         Zone of Visual Influence and Visual Sensitive Receivers

Figure 6.5         Photos of Visual Sensitive Receivers (Sheet 1 of 2)

Figure 6.6         Photos of Visual Sensitive Receivers (Sheet 2 of 2)

Figure 6.7         Key Views from Visual Sensitive Receivers

Figure 6.8         Visual Mitigation Measure Plan

Figure 6.9         Visual Mitigation Measures Section (Sheet 1 of 2)

Figure 6.10       Visual Mitigation Measures Section (Sheet 2 of 2)

Figure 6.11        Viewpoint 1 Photomontage at R1

Figure 6.12        Viewpoint 2 Photomontage at R3

Figure 6.13        Viewpoint 6 Photomontage at OU1

Figure 7.1          Locations of Representative Noise Sensitive Receivers

Figure 7.2          Locations of Noise Barriers for Radiators

 

 

List of Appendices

 

Appendix 3.1     Detailed Calculations of Dust Emission Rates

                        Figure A3.1a      Location of Potential Dust Emission Sources - Phase 1

                        Figure A3.1b      Location of Potential Dust Emission Sources - Phase 2

Appendix 3.2     Detailed Calculations of Emission from New Cremators at Cape Collinson Crematorium

Appendix 3.3     Asbestos Investigation Report and Asbestos Abatement Plan

Appendix 3.4     Summary of the Predicted Air Quality Impacts with the Operation of the Project

Appendix 3.5     Contour of Maximum 1-Hour Average NO2 Concentration in mg/m3 at 161.2mPD

Appendix 3.6     Agreement from FEHD on Assumptions/Design Parameters

Appendix 5.1     Contamination Assessment Plan (CAP)

Appendix 5.2     Contamination Assessment Report / Remediation Action Plan (CAR/RAP)

Appendix 7.1     Measurement Results for Prevailing Daytime and Night-time Noise Levels

Figure A7.1      Measurement Locations for Prevailing Daytime and Night-time Noise Levels

Appendix 7.2     Noise Criteria for Fixed Noise Sources

Appendix 7.3     Photographs of Representative Noise Sensitive Receivers

Appendix 7.4     Powered Mechanical Equipment (PME) for Demolition/Construction Tasks During Normal Daytime Working Hours (Without Mitigation Measures)

Appendix 7.5     Fixed Plant Inventory

Figure A7.5        Locations of Fixed Plant Noise Sources

Appendix 7.6     Calculations of Construction Noise Levels During Normal Daytime Working Hours (Without Mitigation Measures)

Appendix 7.7     Calculations of Fixed Plant Noise (Without Mitigation Measures)

Appendix 7.8     Powered Mechanical Equipment (PME) for Demolition/Construction Tasks During Normal Daytime Working Hours (With Mitigation Measures - Use of Quiet PME)

Appendix 7.9     Calculations of Construction Noise Levels During Normal Daytime Working Hours (With Mitigation Measures)

Appendix 7.10   Calculations of Fixed Plant Noise (With Mitigation Measures)

Appendix 8.1     Foul Water Connection Manhole

Appendix 8.2     Capacity Performance of Existing Sewers in Ultimate Year

Appendix 8.3     Existing Sewers under Assessment